1 Corinthians 12:9
“To another faith by the same Spirit, to another gifts of healing by that one Spirit.”
Read that sentence slowly and a question rises up on its own: what does it even mean to be given faith? Isn’t faith something every believer already has to have, just to be here at all? And healing — if the Spirit hands someone a gift of healing, why doesn’t it stay with them? Why isn’t there a permanent healer in every congregation, someone you could simply go find?
The translations circle the same puzzle from a dozen angles. One calls it “special faith.” Another, “unwavering trust.” One renders the healing side as “the ability to cure the sick”; another, more simply, “the power to heal.” None of them disagree with each other — they’re all reaching for the same thing, and the reaching itself is instructive.
A Faith That Isn’t Ours to Keep
Paul’s word for faith here isn’t the ordinary word for belief. It’s a specific enabling, given for a moment, to do something beyond what the believer could manage on their own strength. The person isn’t holier or more devoted than the rest of the congregation — they’ve simply been handed, briefly, what the moment required.
That’s why it doesn’t stay. It was never a possession to begin with — it was a loan, made for a need, and the need passes.
Healings, Not a Healer
The plural matters too. Not healing, but healings — plural, as if each occasion called for its own fresh gift rather than drawing on a reservoir the person now owned. Scripture backs this up: when a woman touched Jesus’s robe and was healed, He said power had gone out from Him, not out of a gift He was managing. The healing moved through Him; it didn’t belong to Him.
That’s a different picture than the one most of us carry around — a gifted healer, available on call, growing more reliable with practice. Paul’s picture is closer to a window that opens sometimes rather than a tap that’s always on.

Why It Needs an Open Church
This is where Paul’s two examples circle back to the rest of the chapter. He’s not describing private gifting for personal use — he’s describing what a body does when it’s actually functioning as a body. Faith and healing show up where the congregation is porous enough for the Spirit to move through it without resistance.
That kind of openness is costly. It means the congregation can’t hide behind position, tradition, or its own competence. It has to keep asking the Spirit to show up, rather than assuming He already has.
History reads like a long argument for how rarely that openness survives contact with institutions. Something closes over, the connection narrows, and the church settles for managing itself instead of being moved. The early church had it, lost it, and the ache for it keeps resurfacing — not as nostalgia, but as a standing invitation back to the same vulnerability.
The gift was never ours to keep in the first place. It only ever moved through open hands.